... six weeks in the wetlands!
Saturday, October 24, 2020
Thursday, October 22, 2020
getting lost is another way to be found...
One of the inward insights I have gleaned over the past year of repairing our deck, rebuilding stairs, constructing raised bed terraces for our garden, building steps, and painting a great deal inside and outside our home is that I am a kinesthetic learner with an aesthetic disposition. In Howard Gardner's Multiple Intelligence Inventory - a useful summary of the various ways different people learn best - I am off the charts when it comes to Musical as well as Bodily-Kinesthetic intelligence. I knew the former as I hear answers, questions, and even solutions to so much in life in terms of songs, but the later is new to me. (O Lord, do i LOVE this song!)
I knew I had an eye for beauty in my worship and home settings. It was equally clear that I am drawn to the clean lines of Zen/Mission interiors as well as the bold blocks of balanced color of Rothko, Mondrian and a host of French expressionists and impressionists. What I did not understand is that I learn best by doing. Trial and error and beginner's mind come natural to me. Di tells me this is an affinity for what business jargon calls "lateral decisions." Only after I've given a project a shot or two am I interested in reading what others have learned. Out of the box resolutions pop up first. And the lessons that stay with me for the long haul begin with trying to fix something, taking it apart when it doesn't work, and trying again. And again. And again to make it work. I rather like the way Rumi puts it the interpretation Coleman Barks shares in "The Guest House."
This being human is a guest house.
Every morning a new arrival.
A joy, a depression, a meanness,
some momentary awareness comes
as an unexpected visitor.
Welcome and entertain them all!
Even if they are a crowd of sorrows,
who violently sweep your house
empty of its furniture,
still, treat each guest honorably.
He may be clearing you out
for some new delight.
The dark thought, the shame, the malice.
meet them at the door laughing and invite them in.
Be grateful for whatever comes.
because each has been sent
as a guide from beyond.
Every morning a new arrival.
A joy, a depression, a meanness,
some momentary awareness comes
as an unexpected visitor.
Welcome and entertain them all!
Even if they are a crowd of sorrows,
who violently sweep your house
empty of its furniture,
still, treat each guest honorably.
He may be clearing you out
for some new delight.
The dark thought, the shame, the malice.
meet them at the door laughing and invite them in.
Be grateful for whatever comes.
because each has been sent
as a guide from beyond.
Today, after researching and writing about the early celebrations of All Hallow's Eve and All Saints and All Souls Days, I spent four hours up on a ladder painting shutters. I am uncertain of heights and it takes me a while to get my bearings. To be sure, for that first shutter I had a headache and I was sure I was going to puke. But after a glass of water, I kept at it - and incrementally learned how to keep my balance 17' off the ground. I knew that if I left the higher shutters brown while all the others were sky blue, I would have an aesthetic collapse. It would be so ugly and unbalanced. So, I tried. And learned how to make it work as I went along. Along the way I saw that the window sills need to be repainted, too. I will get to that after more writing about the lesser feasts born of ancient Celtic wisdom.
Funny how getting older can resolve some of the questions and doubts of my youth - mostly by pushing through fear with beginner's mind.
Tuesday, October 20, 2020
from howling into silence...
“We cannot become so impatient for the destination that we arrive before we are ready.” Christine Valters Paintner
The Eagle soars in the summit of Heaven,
The Hunter with his dogs pursues his circuit.
O perpetual revolution of configured stars,
O perpetual recurrence of determined seasons,
O world of spring and autumn, birth and dying
The endless cycle of idea and action,
Endless invention, endless experiment,
Brings knowledge of motion, but not of stillness;
Knowledge of speech, but not of silence;
Knowledge of words, and ignorance of the Word.
All our knowledge brings us nearer to our ignorance,
All our ignorance brings us nearer to death,
But nearness to death no nearer to GOD.
Where is the Life we have lost in living?
Where is the wisdom we have lost in knowledge?
Where is the knowledge we have lost in information?
The cycles of Heaven in twenty centuries
Bring us farther from GOD and nearer to the Dust.
This weekend I tapped into my deep longing for human connection during this season of contagion. I wrote about it, I felt it while speaking with my brother by phone on his birthday (he lives in SF), I sensed it swelling up within as we Zoomed with our sweet Brooklyn kin, and I listened to its empty aching last night before going to sleep. Looking out upon the now golden mantle of the wetlands this morning as her deep reds disappear and bright oranges fade, I caught a foretaste of the grays that await us in November. They will shimmer whenever the sun shows up and swirl across the field in nuanced silvers should the shadows prevail. Cumulatively, these sights and sensitivities send me back to words Dr. Valters-Paintner shared in The Soul's Slow Ripening: 12 Celtic Practices for Seeking the Sacred.
One way to practice peregrinatio (pilgrimage) in our lives is to follow the thread which for me means to listen to the synchronicities and patterns being revealed daily. When we are discernment... and pay attention to the other moments that shimmer, we may begin to notice symbols showing up to call us forward.
And maybe not always forward, but also deeper, too. The late James Hillman used to insist that the dominant metaphor of our culture is growth. Accumulation is one-dimensional, however, a construct of economics and adolescent ideology. It is rooted in the mistaken belief that if to have is good then to have more is better. But unrestrained growth becomes cancerous and crowds out the maturation of our soul. To become wise - and authentic - requires going deeper, beyond the obvious, into insights, stories, experiences, needs, desires, and feelings that take time to comprehend. To paraphrase Gertrud Mueller-Nelson, they must simmer and percolate before they achieve significance. Going deeper is how we grasp our purpose, our calling, our essence within our community and our role in any given season of our life. Accumulation merely gives us more of the same old shit. (I am reminded of the Different Drummer ad that prophetically graced NYC subways in the 60's in a manner beyond its creator's imagination...)
This yearning for community, my ravenous appetite for engaging others in words and songs of the soul, has clearly been heightened during the pandemic. But I know it to be a lifetime in the making as well. "The soul's ripening is never to be rushed," Dr. Paintner writes, "it takes a lifetime of work" to realize. "The gift of the contemplative path is a profound honoring of the grace of slowness." My feelings are clues: Hillman speaks of a clue as a symptom, "a compromise between an appropriate relation/action and a sick or wounded one." And like Fr. Ed Hays has taught, our feelings/clues/ symptoms carry meanings. They are the wisdom of our wounds wherein the feeling gets our attention, but our response must almost always be inverted. "When we feel like running away, we would be better served by staying put. When we ache to shout, we should be silent." Call it a revelaltion from the upside-down kingdom, the Paschal Mystery, or the spiritual wisdom of autumn, another invitation to go deeper is brewing.
We can grow impatient when life does not offer us instant insights or gratification. We call on the wisdom of the Celtic monks to accompany us (in these times) to teach us what it means to honor the beauty of wating and attending and witnessing what it is that wants to emerge rather than what our rational minds want to make happen. The soul always offers us more richness that we can imagine, if we only make space and listen. (The Soul's Slow Ripening, p. XV)
So, as best and as imperfectly as I am able, I seek to celebrate this season's call to enter yet again the acumen of silence. Not only will the stillness guide my Sunday reflections, but it will shape my personal contemplative practices, too. This coming Sunday will be an anticipation of All Hallow's Eve en route to All Saints and All Souls days. And then it is on to the quiet of the ancient Celtic Advent that begins on November 15 and runs a full 40 days. Last week I was mostly filled with Ginsberg's "Howl." And rightly so - but now it is time for emptying of T.S. Eliot's "The Rock."
The Eagle soars in the summit of Heaven,
The Hunter with his dogs pursues his circuit.
O perpetual revolution of configured stars,
O perpetual recurrence of determined seasons,
O world of spring and autumn, birth and dying
The endless cycle of idea and action,
Endless invention, endless experiment,
Brings knowledge of motion, but not of stillness;
Knowledge of speech, but not of silence;
Knowledge of words, and ignorance of the Word.
All our knowledge brings us nearer to our ignorance,
All our ignorance brings us nearer to death,
But nearness to death no nearer to GOD.
Where is the Life we have lost in living?
Where is the wisdom we have lost in knowledge?
Where is the knowledge we have lost in information?
The cycles of Heaven in twenty centuries
Bring us farther from GOD and nearer to the Dust.
Monday, October 19, 2020
silence, presence and longing for connections...
One of the hardest and most humbling truths I've encountered involves presence: being a presence for others, welcoming the presence of others when I hurt or know fear, and receiving the presence of the holy who is always present even when I am unperceptive. I'm not sure when I realized why it was hard - at least 30 years ago or more - but I still recall the paradox of experiencing powerlessness and value at the same time. Physically sitting with another as they suffer and/or grieve feels impotent to me for I know that there is nothing I can do to take away their pain. Any attempt to be active in those settings mostly makes matters worse. Simultaneously, sharing my vulnerability and emptiness without illusions often evokes a love and solidarity that is palpable. At least for a moment, while the anguish remains, the agony becomes incrementally lighter to bear. Having been on the receiving end of his miracle, I trust its salvific gift even if I cannot comprehend it.
Men called you light so as to load you down,
And burden you with their own weight of sin,
A woman forced to cover and contain
Those seven devils sent by Everyman.
But one man set you free and took your part
One man knew and loved you to the core
The broken alabaster of your heart
Revealed to Him alone a hidden door,
Into a garden where the fountain sealed,
Could flow at last for him in healing tears,
Till, in another garden, he revealed
The perfect Love that cast out all your fears,
And quickened you with love’s own sway and swing,
As light and lovely as the news you bring.
The constant in experiencing, witnessing, and sharing this blessing is silence. As the moderator of the Contemplative Outreach FB group noted: "When going through a storm, your silent presence is more powerful than a million words." Silence becomes sacramental in its healing mode - and that is yet another reason why presence feels so hard - to enter, trust, and nourish silence when surrounded by pain takes practice and faith. By nature we want to help. To fix. To resolve. Deep within I suspect we know there is nothing we can do, yet "doing" gives us meaning and validation. It is the way of the world. To resist doing, therefore, is so very counter-cultural. Not only does it look as useless as Sabbath, it can feel that way in our hearts - at least for a time. Only those willing to walk through the valley of the shadow of death in silence, however, get to taste and see the goodness of the Lord. Those who pray, "How long, O Lord?" silently in their souls while sitting still in the aching quiet get to join Mary Magdalene in greeting the risen presence of the holy in our humanity. Malcolm Guite puts it like this in his sonnet to Mary Magdalene:
Men called you light so as to load you down,
And burden you with their own weight of sin,
A woman forced to cover and contain
Those seven devils sent by Everyman.
But one man set you free and took your part
One man knew and loved you to the core
The broken alabaster of your heart
Revealed to Him alone a hidden door,
Into a garden where the fountain sealed,
Could flow at last for him in healing tears,
Till, in another garden, he revealed
The perfect Love that cast out all your fears,
And quickened you with love’s own sway and swing,
As light and lovely as the news you bring.
(Sounding the Seasons, Malcolm Guite https://canterburypress.hymnsam.co.uk//product-display?isbn=9781848252745)
For the last few days I have been aching for the sounds and solace of being with others in community. I've even flirted with violating my own sanity and inviting a few local people to join me on Sunday morning when I try to hold my FB live stream outside in our wee chapel. I know better. It is covid exhaustion speaking to me like the serpent in the garden. And I won't go there. What do they say about coincidence? It is God's way of remaining anonymous? Yesterday, while Zooming with our loved ones in Brooklyn, we spoke of possible Christmas visits. I am slowly working on our basement to become decent living quarters for family visits. It is a great space but will take lots of work and is a winter project. During this chat, my wise daughter said something like, "We could even put off celebrating Christmas by a few weeks so that we all are certain about the safety of our bubble. I want to be extra, extra careful about this for you, ok?" Her words echoed in my heart last night as I put to rest - at least for now - any other thoughts of sharing Sunday's Eucharist in community. On a whole other level, its time for me to befriend the silence yet again. The wise and wounded Jan Richardson wrote this Blessing for the Chaos that I am going to print out and post on my prayer wall:
To all that is chaotic in you,
let there come silence.
Let there be a calming of the clamoring,
a stilling of the voices
that have laid their claim on you,
that have made their home in you
that go with you even to the holy places
but will not let you rest,
will not let you hear your life with wholeness.
let there come silence.
Let there be a calming of the clamoring,
a stilling of the voices
that have laid their claim on you,
that have made their home in you
that go with you even to the holy places
but will not let you rest,
will not let you hear your life with wholeness.
For the foreseeable future - at least the next nine months and probably longer - I am being called (WE are being called!) to be at peace with a lot more silence. This will come to pass. This is not the end. And within the silence are moments of conversation and presence I can learn to savor like going to vote at City Hall (momentarily) or visiting the library in full PPE regalia. And then, as I've seen posted so often recently, with the season of shared solitude is over, THEN we can embrace and rejoice and experience another layer of presence. But now is not that time...
Sunday, October 18, 2020
reflections from the chapel?
Next Sunday, if the weather cooperates, I am going to try doing my live-streaming reflection outside in our emerging chapel. It will be the last weekend of October. I want to ready our hearts and minds for All Saints and All Souls Days and open the door for others to join me in observing the ancient Celtic Advent that begins on Sunday, November 15. (More on this as it is mirrored by the Eastern Orthodox tradition.) I will be experimenting with equipment, extension chords, microphones, etc. this week. And while it may all come to naught if it rains, I think it could be fun. Here are a few teasers I took after today's yard work. A friend posted a poem by John O'Donohue that speaks to this transitional time in the seasons and the liturgy.
Lie low to the wall
Until the bitter weather passes
Try, as best you can, not to let
The wire brush of doubt
Scrape from your heart
All sense of yourself
And your hesitant light.
If you remain generous,
Time will come good;
And you will find your feet
Again on fresh pastures of promise,
Where the air will be kind
And blushed with beginning.
Tuesday, October 13, 2020
getting ready to lean into my darkness...
Today is all reds, browns, and yellows in the wetland. The sky is gray, filled with an insistent rain pulsating with the promises of autumn. This is the season we learn about letting go: letting go of the sun and its warmth, letting go of the garden and its bounty, letting go of simple walks without serious preparation, letting go of the leaves, the flowers, and so much of our outward lives. For those in New England, and even more so in Canada, daylight will come to a crashing close in a few weeks when 4 pm becomes nightfall. This takes some getting used to and even the natives find themselves in the throes of periodic depression as we move towards All Saints Day in November. Doctors have documented a Vitamin D deficiency among many of us as well.
The moon drops one or two feathers into the field.
The dark wheat listens.
Be still.
Now.
There they are, the moon's young, trying
Their wings.
Between trees, a slender woman lifts up the lovely shadow
Of her face, and now she steps into the air, now she is gone
Wholly, into the air.
I stand alone by an elder tree, I do not dare breathe
Or move.
I listen.
The wheat leans back toward its own darkness,
And I lean toward mine.
In two weeks time, all the colors of the field will vanish except nuanced browns and grays as a stern starkness seizes the day. The obvious complaint with this shift is its severity. The exuberance of summer must give way to introspection as
externals are put on hold and we start to hunker down. Nature invites us to prepare for this transformation, but our eyes must stay open as this turning point moves quickly. A wise colleague captured the challenge of this upheaval well stating that when our only seasonal produce has been reduced to maple syrup, no matter how delicious, something new is coming. The autumnal equinox kicks it off. Christopher Hill writes in Holidays and Holy Nights that "autumn is poignant... piercing our hearts and waking us from drowsy summer... with a sharp longing for something else."
We humans see the spiritual beauty of a thing most clearly when its time is passing or passed. Nothing becomes legendary or sacred until it dies. In autumn, natures time is passing. The world is at its most beautiful and poetic because it is passing away. The natural world lingers for a moment on the bring of this transformation... with a bitter sweet beauty that we are about lose. The light turns from the clear, practical white light of summer into the mellow gold that we call antique - like the yellowed pages of an old boo, the sepia of old photographs, or tarnished brass. Old light, legends of the fall, Indian summer. Nature (already) has one foot over the threshold of eternity and glows with a slant of light
from the other side of the door.
I rarely grasp this at first. Being distracted by pumpkins and gourds, apple cider and a limited run of pumpkin chai from David's Teas, I'm consumed with the cornucopia of colors among the trees, wild grass, golden rod, asters, grape vines, and sumac. Something in my soul is dazzled by the deep, root-like hues of the countryside this time of year and I lose track of time. Only when the upper leaves of the massive wetland's oak turns red can I confess that fall is upon us. It doesn't matter how long I've been raking leaves or fertilizing garden beds, that tree is what I need to know that now it is leave-taking time. Soon there will be a chill in the air, a stripping of color from the hills, and a shroud of darkness that won't give up the ghost until late February.
Parker Palmer believes that during this time of transition nature is engaged in a paradox of dying and seeding." Faced with (the departure of summer and the inevitability of) winter, what does nature do in autumn? She scatters the seeds that will bring new growth in the spring—and she scatters them with amazing abandon." (The Paradox of Fall, Fetzer Institute) Christopher Hill adds another layer of depth to this tension:
In summer we celebrate our at-homeness in the world. Michalemas (the Feast Day of the Archangel Michael on September 29) balances that feeling. In autumn we feel our not-at-homeness, the sense of wanting something else, something we can't name... Summer is static - in Latin, solstice means 'the stationary sun." (That makes) summer a sacrament of natural harmony with God, when we can see that 'fallen nature' is really only nature seen with fallen eyes, and that all around us paradise is still going on... Autumn is not dreaming time... and the flaming trees say it all: they are a last flare of gorgeousness before death as well as a signal fire, a wake-up call to the soul... as we encounter the conflict between light and dark. (Hill, pp. 36-37)
First, there is the robust beauty; then, the austerity arrives. September and October ask us to bask in the abundance of creation's bounty as preparation for the emptiness to come physically, emotionally, and spiritually. We not only bring in the harvest and care for the hearth, we intentionally let go of what is over, what is old, what is no longer real. For this, it seems to me, is how to embrace the blessings and wisdom of God's first word in creation. We read the signs of the time. Early autumn shows us what it looks like to release what no longer serves us. As leaves fall and blow away, so too with some "possessions, relationships, old habits of thought and behavior." (Hill, p. 42) Recognizing and naming what is complete, helps ready me for the rigors of November and the anticipations of Advent. The ancient Celtic Church, like contemporary Eastern Orthodoxy, observed Advent from November 15 - December 24. Restoring two weeks to Advent feels right to me after honoring the Vigil of All Hallows Eve (Halloween) as well as both All Saints Day and the Feast of the Faithful Departed on All Souls Day.
Perhaps it is an awareness wrought by the pandemic. It could be the damp chill in the air. Or even the slow connections I discern as I ripen into retirement. What ever the origins, I want to be ready - and still like James Wright in his poem, Beginning - to lean into my darkness.
The dark wheat listens.
Be still.
Now.
There they are, the moon's young, trying
Their wings.
Between trees, a slender woman lifts up the lovely shadow
Of her face, and now she steps into the air, now she is gone
Wholly, into the air.
I stand alone by an elder tree, I do not dare breathe
Or move.
I listen.
The wheat leans back toward its own darkness,
And I lean toward mine.
Sunday, October 11, 2020
a work in progress...
So my attempts at staying grounded in community during this season of solitude are... a work in progress, ok? Today's live-streaming reflection felt good while I was sharing it, only to find out afterwards there was a glitch and hiccup in the vocal track. It wasn't a terrible problem, but a bit of a hassle. Who know's why? I will search for solutions and try to rectify them this week.
That said, two other ideas have floated to the surface: intercessory prayer and questions. When I started this over the weekend of March 13th who knew it would still be going on? Morphing and evolving, too? A few of you have sent me notes from time to time, or left messages on the Small is Holy FB page, with encouragement and suggestions. Let me now take this one step farther because not much is going to change for most of us over the next nine months. That is, we are going to remain in some form of self-imposed or mandated solitude for health reasons well through the first half of 2021. That is according to our best medical folk and, of course, not the Virus-in-Chief.
So, what are your thoughts and needs re: intercessory prayer? Some folk call this joys and concerns - other prayer requests - but by whatever title you use, what I'm talking about is making your prayer known so that during our live-streaming time we can pray for you together by name. Thoughts? Prayers? Concerns? What I was thinking of was: 1) At the start of each gathering, you might type a word or a sentence that you would like held in prayer, either during the opening music or the introduction and Scripture. That way, when we get to the time of Eucharist at the close we can add your prayers. And/or 2) send me a note by email or FB sometime throughout the week.
And, what about follow-up questions? Given the live-streaming format, while I am keenly aware of your presence, the medium is still one-directional: from me to you. (And as you know from dropping microphones and all the rest, I am not wildly tech savvy and have no real interest in the whole Zoom phenomena (we use it with the grandchildren and at L'Arche but that's different.) What do you think? Would you ever want clarifications or sources? Are there themes you might value a series on? Or something you would like to explore more profoundly? Let me know if any of that appeals to you, ok?
Let me know, please? Drop me a note on FB or send me an email. I would be grateful to take this deeper even as I try to work out the techno bumps in the road. It is, indeed, a work in progress. Here is a recap of today's video.
Saturday, October 10, 2020
a thousand beautiful things...
Oh, my Lord, what a morning! Sweet sunlight, cool breezes, burning bushes
ablaze and breakfast on the deck in the autumn stillness. I am trying to practice what I preach - and will share tomorrow morning on the live-streaming gathering - about treasuring gratitude. And then, as if the cosmos thought I needed a gentle but real kick in the pants, I came upon this poem: "Wishing Well" by Gregory Pardlo (You can hear Pádraig Ó Tuama read it @ https://onbeing.
org/poetry/wishing-well/ and it is well worth the effort.)
“Outside the Met a man walks up sun
tweaking the brim sticker on his Starter cap
and he says pardon me Old School he
says you know is this a wishing well?
Yeah Son I say sideways over my shrug.
Throw your bread on the water.
I tighten my chest wheezy as Rockaway beach
sand with a pull of faux smoke on my e-cig
to cozy the truculence I hotbox alone
and I am at the museum because it is not a bar.
Because he appears not to have changed
them in days I eye the heel-chewed hems
of his pants and think probably he will
ask me for fifty cents any minute now wait
for it. A smoke or something. Central Park displays
the frisking transparency of autumn. Tracing
paper sky, leaves like eraser crumbs gum
the pavement. As if deciphering celestial
script I squint and purse off toward the roof
line of the museum aloof as he fists two
pennies from his pockets mumbling and then
aloud my man he says hey my man I’m going
to make a wish for you too.
I am laughing now so what you want
me to sign a waiver? He laughs along ain’t
say all that he says but you do have to
hold my hand. And close your eyes.
I make a starless night of my face before
he asks are you ready. Yeah dawg I’m ready.
Sure? Sure let’s do this his rough hand
in mine inflates like a blood pressure cuff and I
squeeze back as if we are about to step together
from the sill of all resentment and timeless
toward the dreamsource of un-needing the two
of us hurtle sharing the cosmic breast
of plenitude when I hear the coins blink against
the surface and I cough up daylight like I’ve just
been dragged ashore. See now
you’ll never walk alone he jokes and is about
to hand me back to the day he found me in
like I was a rubber duck and he says you got to let
go but I feel bottomless and I know he means
well though I don’t believe
and I feel myself shaking
my head no when he means let go his hand.”
Annie Lennox and Rumi insist that there are a thousand ways to kneel and kiss the earth with a heart of gratitude. The more I listen - and practice - and honor this truth, the less fear and cynicism I know. And the more I find to be grateful for. Nothing has changed objectively in the body politic, of course, that remains a mess. But now I am living into its fullness rather than just being carried away on the surface of my feelings.
Friday, October 9, 2020
background and context for my debate critique...
In a recent FB post, I suggested that those who choose not to watch the ethically and emotionally complicated political debates - for whatever reasons - do so. In an earlier post I encouraged practicing self-care in this highly charged and life-threatening political season - a practice that must respect our mental and spiritual health. Others far wiser than I, have recommended only one hour a day of political "news" with lots of time for silence, nature, and beauty. That continues to be my default position.
At the same time, however, I've expressed my frustration with FB opinions that seem to conflate an individual's emotional distress with broken politics. In my experience, the two are unrelated. To be sure, those of us who hail from privileged backgrounds (myself included) and came of age after years of respectable public conversations, debate societies, dance lessons, decades of social etiquette cues, suburban religious congregations, well-manicured lawns, and all the other public advantages afforded to children of corporate America: we detest disorder. With modest variations, we shrink from shrill and boisterous arguments. We resist being caught up in aggressive altercations of any type. And we tend to believe that the world should work in a decent and well-ordered way. This is not to say that there was no stress, pain, or heartbreak in our formation. All human beings know suffering of one type or another. Nevertheless, those of us from a discrete social class despise chaos.
For the first 35 years of my life, my political engagement was fundamentally well ordered: I applied for Conscientious Objector status when I registered with the local draft board at age 18, I worked that process with the assistance of professionals at the American Friends Service Committee, my local church not only had a carefully organized way for me to declare my intentions re: ministry but also for noting my moral opposition to war, the draft board hearing in Norwalk, CT was well run by well-trained managers, my subsequent years organizing with Cesar Chavez and the Farm Workers Union included carefully planned social protest with the help of well-trained lawyers, etc. My participation in public demonstrations against the Vietnam War and Richard Nixon came with clear guidelines and expert organization. You get the picture: social engagement, even in opposition to the status quo, was conducted in a reasonable and decent way as is befitting my bourgeois background.
That bubble burst when I became involved in the rough and tumble politics of urban Cleveland. There was nothing bourgeois about winning an election in that town - or I might note in most of the rest of America. It did not work like my civics textbooks suggested. It was not well-ordered and rarely civil. Peoples' lives were at stake. So, too, their livelihoods and neighborhoods. I still recall with awe my first "debate" at the Polish Hall in Slavic Village. I was running for school board as part of Mayor Michael R. White's inter-racial reform team. We were challenging the entrenched political hacks and union bosses who had perpetuated decades of nepotism, cronyism, and bleeding the public trough for personal gain without ever advancing educational opportunity for the mostly poor, Black children of Cleveland. The budget of the Cleveland Board of Education was greater than that of the city of Cleveland so a ton of money was at risk.
I lived on the West Side of Cleveland, the mostly white, working class neighborhoods in an aggressively segregated city. There were pockets of wealth on the West Side as well as middle class neighborhoods that looked and acted like the suburbs of my youth. The East Side was mostly black, fundamentally poor, but with middle class pockets spread around that periphery, too. And in the center of town, in the old Eastern European neighborhoods was Slavic Village - a bastion of old-world culture - with all the blessings and curses of that reality. Our team was scheduled to debate their team - a cadre of old school, white ethnic pols with well-known names - and as soon as I stepped into the debate hall it was like Dorothy in the Wizard of Oz: "We're not in Kansas anymore, Toto." This was NOT the Citizens League endorsement committee. The beer was flowing, the tough white crowd was pumped up and angry, and I was certain I was going to get my then skinny white ass kicked multiple times that night. The short version is we made our pitch to cat calls, yells, racial slurs, and a host of other vulgar and ugly epithets. And thanks be to God the Mayor's team was there to make sure that after the ruckus we all got to our cars safely. For me, it was trial by fire.
THIS was how politics was done outside of my bubble. THIS was how it worked when political choices mattered, not as abstract preferences, but in life and death ways. I can't say I ever learned to be at home in that world. I still preferred the bourgeois cocktail parties in the middle-class neighborhoods of Black and White Cleveland. There I could speak without interruption, make the good government case with clarity, and answer well-formed questions But I learned. I got better at dealing with the verbal sparring and the potential for violence. And I listened to the pros about how to take care of myself in the fray. Four years ago, driving through Kentucky and Pennsylvania on the way to the wedding of two friends, I felt I was back in Slavic Village. The anger in the air was palpable. The rabid support for Trump was visceral and omnipresent. And, once again, I had to hurry through most places for fear of getting my ass kicked again. There was anger, heartbreak, and fear pulsating there in ways I had forgotten about in my Western Massachusetts middle class bubble.
All of which is to say: it is OK to be emotionally uncomfortable with the rage of this era. It is unsettling and sometimes terrifying. So, too, with the political debates: if they make you upset, please don't watch them. Take care of yourself. But let's not condemn what takes place at the debates from the limited perspective of our comfortable bubbles. It is not useful to confuse our dis-ease with exaggerated moral judgment. That's been my biggest concern and critique. And, yes, I still find carping about the impotence of the moderators disingenuous. They are operating from within a bubble, too and are only now getting up to speed about how to respond to the political chaos that is normative. Have you ever watched British Parliament? It is boorish and cruel, loud, and mean-spirited as well. From my limited perspective, however, their shouting is more like what politics looks, feels, and sounds like in most of the world than what I grew up with.
So, that's where I'm coming from. The medieval monk, Meister Eckhart, once said something like: Reality is the will of God. It can always be better, but you must start with what is real. And while what I see in our politics and debates is not pretty, it is real. The debate moderators are striving for the best they can do with what is real. My hope is that we do likewise with a minimum of judgment.
At the same time, however, I've expressed my frustration with FB opinions that seem to conflate an individual's emotional distress with broken politics. In my experience, the two are unrelated. To be sure, those of us who hail from privileged backgrounds (myself included) and came of age after years of respectable public conversations, debate societies, dance lessons, decades of social etiquette cues, suburban religious congregations, well-manicured lawns, and all the other public advantages afforded to children of corporate America: we detest disorder. With modest variations, we shrink from shrill and boisterous arguments. We resist being caught up in aggressive altercations of any type. And we tend to believe that the world should work in a decent and well-ordered way. This is not to say that there was no stress, pain, or heartbreak in our formation. All human beings know suffering of one type or another. Nevertheless, those of us from a discrete social class despise chaos.
For the first 35 years of my life, my political engagement was fundamentally well ordered: I applied for Conscientious Objector status when I registered with the local draft board at age 18, I worked that process with the assistance of professionals at the American Friends Service Committee, my local church not only had a carefully organized way for me to declare my intentions re: ministry but also for noting my moral opposition to war, the draft board hearing in Norwalk, CT was well run by well-trained managers, my subsequent years organizing with Cesar Chavez and the Farm Workers Union included carefully planned social protest with the help of well-trained lawyers, etc. My participation in public demonstrations against the Vietnam War and Richard Nixon came with clear guidelines and expert organization. You get the picture: social engagement, even in opposition to the status quo, was conducted in a reasonable and decent way as is befitting my bourgeois background.
That bubble burst when I became involved in the rough and tumble politics of urban Cleveland. There was nothing bourgeois about winning an election in that town - or I might note in most of the rest of America. It did not work like my civics textbooks suggested. It was not well-ordered and rarely civil. Peoples' lives were at stake. So, too, their livelihoods and neighborhoods. I still recall with awe my first "debate" at the Polish Hall in Slavic Village. I was running for school board as part of Mayor Michael R. White's inter-racial reform team. We were challenging the entrenched political hacks and union bosses who had perpetuated decades of nepotism, cronyism, and bleeding the public trough for personal gain without ever advancing educational opportunity for the mostly poor, Black children of Cleveland. The budget of the Cleveland Board of Education was greater than that of the city of Cleveland so a ton of money was at risk.
I lived on the West Side of Cleveland, the mostly white, working class neighborhoods in an aggressively segregated city. There were pockets of wealth on the West Side as well as middle class neighborhoods that looked and acted like the suburbs of my youth. The East Side was mostly black, fundamentally poor, but with middle class pockets spread around that periphery, too. And in the center of town, in the old Eastern European neighborhoods was Slavic Village - a bastion of old-world culture - with all the blessings and curses of that reality. Our team was scheduled to debate their team - a cadre of old school, white ethnic pols with well-known names - and as soon as I stepped into the debate hall it was like Dorothy in the Wizard of Oz: "We're not in Kansas anymore, Toto." This was NOT the Citizens League endorsement committee. The beer was flowing, the tough white crowd was pumped up and angry, and I was certain I was going to get my then skinny white ass kicked multiple times that night. The short version is we made our pitch to cat calls, yells, racial slurs, and a host of other vulgar and ugly epithets. And thanks be to God the Mayor's team was there to make sure that after the ruckus we all got to our cars safely. For me, it was trial by fire.
THIS was how politics was done outside of my bubble. THIS was how it worked when political choices mattered, not as abstract preferences, but in life and death ways. I can't say I ever learned to be at home in that world. I still preferred the bourgeois cocktail parties in the middle-class neighborhoods of Black and White Cleveland. There I could speak without interruption, make the good government case with clarity, and answer well-formed questions But I learned. I got better at dealing with the verbal sparring and the potential for violence. And I listened to the pros about how to take care of myself in the fray. Four years ago, driving through Kentucky and Pennsylvania on the way to the wedding of two friends, I felt I was back in Slavic Village. The anger in the air was palpable. The rabid support for Trump was visceral and omnipresent. And, once again, I had to hurry through most places for fear of getting my ass kicked again. There was anger, heartbreak, and fear pulsating there in ways I had forgotten about in my Western Massachusetts middle class bubble.
All of which is to say: it is OK to be emotionally uncomfortable with the rage of this era. It is unsettling and sometimes terrifying. So, too, with the political debates: if they make you upset, please don't watch them. Take care of yourself. But let's not condemn what takes place at the debates from the limited perspective of our comfortable bubbles. It is not useful to confuse our dis-ease with exaggerated moral judgment. That's been my biggest concern and critique. And, yes, I still find carping about the impotence of the moderators disingenuous. They are operating from within a bubble, too and are only now getting up to speed about how to respond to the political chaos that is normative. Have you ever watched British Parliament? It is boorish and cruel, loud, and mean-spirited as well. From my limited perspective, however, their shouting is more like what politics looks, feels, and sounds like in most of the world than what I grew up with.
So, that's where I'm coming from. The medieval monk, Meister Eckhart, once said something like: Reality is the will of God. It can always be better, but you must start with what is real. And while what I see in our politics and debates is not pretty, it is real. The debate moderators are striving for the best they can do with what is real. My hope is that we do likewise with a minimum of judgment.
Wednesday, October 7, 2020
four encouraging words for the final three weeks before the US election...
Four words of encouragement for the next three weeks before the election in the USA:
1) Sit with some beauty so that you can balance the bullshit. I recommend Padraig O Tuama`s poetic reflections @ Poetry Unbound (https://onbeing.
1) Sit with some beauty so that you can balance the bullshit. I recommend Padraig O Tuama`s poetic reflections @ Poetry Unbound (https://onbeing.
org/series/poetry-unbound/). But do whatever nourishes your soul.
2) Make certain to get outside and breathe in some fresh air because Mother Nature is a time-tested healer. Autumn is a season of spiritual transition and we are being asked to learn to let go: so be like the leaves in the NE and recognize that the old order is dying and something new is about to be born that is beyond our control. But, please, take time to be still - and breathe.
3) Stay in touch with those you love - and make the effort to go the extra mile. Love heals all wounds. All fears. All anxieties. Not perfectly. And not always the way we want. But, in the long run, in the ways we need. (Oh yes, and BLOCK all trolls as they will eat your heart and wear out your soul.)
4) Try to limit your time with so-called news to one hour every day. Total. Don't cheat. Take in what is happening. Hold it close in prayer. And then let it go - any more time with the craziness is like worry which some have called praying for something bad to happen.
2) Make certain to get outside and breathe in some fresh air because Mother Nature is a time-tested healer. Autumn is a season of spiritual transition and we are being asked to learn to let go: so be like the leaves in the NE and recognize that the old order is dying and something new is about to be born that is beyond our control. But, please, take time to be still - and breathe.
3) Stay in touch with those you love - and make the effort to go the extra mile. Love heals all wounds. All fears. All anxieties. Not perfectly. And not always the way we want. But, in the long run, in the ways we need. (Oh yes, and BLOCK all trolls as they will eat your heart and wear out your soul.)
4) Try to limit your time with so-called news to one hour every day. Total. Don't cheat. Take in what is happening. Hold it close in prayer. And then let it go - any more time with the craziness is like worry which some have called praying for something bad to happen.
Tuesday, October 6, 2020
a radical unity...
Now that the Season of Creation has come to a close - the new liturgical season celebrated ecumenically as a way to deepen human solidarity with the holy throughout the cosmos - those who join me for our Sunday morning reflections on FB live will return to readings from the Common Lectionary of the Ecumenical Church. This practice not only grounds us the shared Bible texts being used for worship throughout the world, but also invites us into a vision and rhythm of life greater than our own. Without this window into the bigger picture, it is too easy for me to become self-absorbed and/or overwhelmed by the events surrounding me. Being connected to sisters and brothers throughout the world in prayer, study, and the practice of sharing common readings in worship helps nurture a measure of stillness and solidarity within.
The second, a contemporary hymn set to a traditional Celtic melody, was equally counter cultural:
Two Celtic songs from the Wild Goose Collective affiliated with the Community of Iona spoke to me this morning in prayer. Textually and melodically these songs reunited my being with the wider creation. The first, an interpretation of Psalm 138 for the opening of Morning Prayer, starts with these words:
I shall praise you, O God, from my soul
Though my song be at odds with the will of earthly gods:
I shall praise you, O God, from my soul.
Don't dull my mind with fickle thoughts of grace without a ground.
I need to know that God is real, I need to know that Christ can feel the need to touch and love and heal the world - including me!
Don't speak of piety and prayers divorced from human need;
Don't talk of spirit without flesh like harvest without seed.
Last night I read in Steven Chase's fascinating and dense work, Nature as Spiritual Practice, of the subtle but real distinctions between the words earth, nature, and creation. Each celebrates connections, yet each also focuses attention on discrete specialties as well. What I am learning to see is how layer upon layer of creation shares a living inter-connection between things seen and those experienced by faith. Between flora and fauna in nature and humankind on earth. Between we who dwell on earth and the sacred throughout the cosmos. I suspect my growing appreciation for the intricate ways all of life is united will inform Sunday's meditation. I am going to walk around with this notion for another day before beginning my Scripture study and intentional writing. Besides, today there's outdoor work to be done in the sun before the anticipated rains of tomorrow.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
finally...
These past three months have taken their toll. Grief and anxiety will do that even if you don't fully recognize the signs. I certainly d...
-
One of the most complex challenges I experience doing ministry in this ever-shifting moment in history has to do with radical Christian love...
-
After four hard and beautiful days with family in anticipation of my father's death, we are home. It was time well spent. As one friend ...


























